Saturday, 22 June 2013

District Run-Down (2 of 6) - Western Australia

We continue our look at the seats of this election with the Western Australian electoral districts. I should stress that these are not predictions, merely the results of analysis. This may serve as a rough approximation of how a seat would be likely to fall if the polling were neck-and-neck and no other factors were at play -- a baseline of each seat's bias to serve as a starting point when we come to make our predictions.

If anyone should disagree with this analysis, feeling that a seat is safer or more marginal than reported here or that some vital factor independent of the current electoral cycle has not been accounted for, feel free (as always) to comment. This series of posts is not merely part of my own working out, it is intended as a point from which any interested person can begin to form their own predictions.

This is the second of six such posts, scheduled thusly:
      June 15th: South Australia (X)
June 22nd: Western Australia
June 29th: Victoria
July 6th: Queensland 
July 13th: New South Wales
July 20th: Tasmania, Northern Territory and Australian Capital Territory
Now, without further ado:

Western Australia:

Western Australia's economy is driven largely by the primary sector, specifically the extraction and processing of mineral and petroleum resources, although other chemical and agricultural exports are also major players (source). The state government is bicameral and based on the Westminster system, and has arguably been the strongest defender of state autonomy, with secession from the Federation a recurring theme in the state's political history. The lower house (Legeslative Assembly) contains 31 Liberal members, 21 Liberal and 7 Nationals. The upper house (Legislative Council) is held by 17 Liberal councillors, 11 Labor councillors, 5 Nationals, 2 Greens and 1 councillor from the Shooters and Fishers party.

The state contains 15 electoral districts, and as a state elects 6 Senators to the Federal Parliament.

How to Read These Summaries:

Incumbent: Incumbent lists the current member for the seat and their current party.

Incumbent/Party Run: Incumbent run provides the number of elections won by the current member, and the years of those elections in parentheses. By-elections are ignored.

A second line may be present and indicate the number of elections won by the current member's party, if this is different to the number won by the current member. Again the years of those elections in parentheses, and again by-elections are ignored.

2010 Margin (TPP): This is the margin by which the seat was won after the last redistribution of preferences in the 2010 federal election, and who this margin was against.

Electoral History: A list of previous incumbent parties from the foundation of the seat to the present.

Longest Electoral Run: The most elections won in a row in this seat by one party, with the years of those elections in parentheses and the party which won the seat in those elections.

State Divisions: The state seats within this federal seat. The seat names are coloured according to their current incumbent (blue for Liberal, red for ALP, dark yellow for Nationals). The last state election was in 2013.

Assessment: An assessment of the seats political history - that is, whether the seat is traditionally of one party or another. This is only approximated from the data here, does not constitute a prediction and may differ from the current incumbent's party.

Brand:

Incumbent: Gary Gray (ALP)
Incumbent/Party Run: 2 Elections won (2007 - Present)
10 Elections won (1984 - Present)
2010 Margin (TPP): 3.33% against LIB
Electoral History: 1984-Present: ALP
Longest Electoral Run:  10 Elections won (1984 - Present) - ALP
State Divisions: Kwinana, part of Mandurah, Rockingham and Warnbro
Assessment: Stable, safe ALP (despite small margin and short history)

 

Canning:

Incumbent: Don Randall (LIB)
Incumbent/Party Run: 4 Elections won (2001 - Present)
2010 Margin (TPP): 2.19% against ALP
Electoral History: 1949–1961: Country Party
1961–1963: LIB
1963–1974: Country Party
1974–1983: LIB
1983–1996: ALP
1996–1998: LIB
1998–2001: ALP
2001–present: LIB
Longest Electoral Run: 5 Elections won (1949 - 1961) - Country Party, (1983-1996) - ALP
State Divisions: Part of Armadale, part of Darling Range, Dawesville, part of Mandurah, part of Murray-Wellington and part of Wagin
Assessment: Variable, leaning to LIB

 

Cowan:

Incumbent: Luke Simpkins (LIB)
Incumbent/Party Run: 2 Elections won (2007 - Present)
2010 Margin (TPP): 6.29% against ALP
Electoral History: 1984–1993: ALP
1993–1998: LIB
1998–2007: ALP
2007–present: LIB
Longest Electoral Run: 3 Elections won (1984–1993) - ALP, (1998–2007) - ALP
State Divisions: Part of Girrawheen, Kingsley, part of Nollamara, part of Wanneroo and part of West Swan
Assessment: Volatile, tossup

 

Curtin:

Incumbent: Julie Bishop (LIB)
Incumbent/Party Run: 5 Elections won (1998 - Present)
2010 Margin (TPP): 16.19% against ALP
Electoral History: 1949-1996: LIB
1996-1998: IND
1998-Present: LIB
Longest Electoral Run: 19 Elections won (1949 - 1996) - LIB
State Divisions: Churchlands, part of Cottesloe, Nedlands, part of Perth and part of Scarborough
Assessment: Stable, very safe LIB

 

Durack:

Incumbent: Barry Haase (LIB)
Incumbent/Party Run: 1 Election won (2010 - Present)
2010 Margin (TPP): 3.67% against ALP
Electoral History: 2010 - Present: LIB
Longest Electoral Run: 1 Election won (2010 - Present) - LIB
State Divisions: Part of Central Wheatbelt, part of Geraldton, part of Kalgoorlie, Kimberly, part of Moore, North West and part of Pilbara
Assessment: Tossup (insufficient data)
N.B.: Any assessment of Durack, which was formed last election, must be premature given only one piece of data.
The state divisions that make up Durack might indicate that a Nationals candidate would do well here. Though they received less than 18% of the primary vote in 2010, things look better for them since the 2013 state election. However, if I understand the Liberal-National agreement, the Nats will not challenge the seat since it has a Liberal Incumbent. However, this was not the case in O'Connor in 2010...

 

Forrest:

Incumbent: Nola Marino (LIB)
Incumbent/Party Run: 2 Elections won (2007 - Present)
16 Elections won (1972 - Present)
2010 Margin (TPP): 8.74% against ALP
Electoral History: 1922–1943: Country Party
1943–1949: ALP
1949–1969: LIB
1969–1972: ALP
1972–present: LIB
Longest Electoral Run: 16 Elections won (1972 - Present) - LIB
State Divisions: Part of Blackwood-Stirling, Bunbury, Collie-Preston, part of Murray-Wellington and Vasse
Assessment: Stable, very safe LIB

 

Fremantle:

Incumbent: Melissa Parke (ALP)
Incumbent/Party Run: 2 Elections won (2007 - Present)
30 Elections won (1934 - Present)
2010 Margin (TPP): 5.70% against LIB
Electoral History: 1901–1903: Free Trade Party
1903–1906: ALP
1906–1909: Western Australian Party**
1909–1913: Commonwealth Liberal Party*
1913–1916: ALP
1913–1916: National Labor Party*
1917–1922: Nationalist Party
1922–1928: IND
1928–1931: ALP
1931–1934: United Australia Party
1934–present: ALP
Longest Electoral Run: 30 Elections won (1934 - Present) - ALP
State Divisions:  Part of Alfred Cove, Cockburn, part of Cottesloe, Fremantle, part of Jandakot and part of Willagee.
Assessment: Stable, very safe ALP

 

Hasluck:

Incumbent: Ken Wyatt (LIB)
Incumbent/Party Run: 1 Election won (2010 - Present)
2010 Margin (TPP): 0.57% against ALP
Electoral History: 2001–2004: ALP
2004–2007: LIB
2007–2010: ALP
2010–present: LIB
Longest Electoral Run: 1 Election won (2001–2004) - ALP, (2004–2007) - LIB, (2007–2010) - ALP, (2010–present) - LIB
State Divisions: Part of Belmont, part of Cannington, part of Forrestfield, Gosnells, part of Kalamunda, part of Midland, part of Southern River and part of West Swan
Assessment: Tossup

 

Moore:

Incumbent: Mal Washer (LIB)
Incumbent/Party Run: 5 Elections won (1998 - Present)
2010 Margin (TPP): 11.19% against ALP
Electoral History: 1949–1958: Country Party
1958–1961: LIB
1961–1974: Country Party
1974–1983: LIB
1983–1990: ALP
1990–1995: LIB
1995–1998: IND
1998–present: LIB
Longest Electoral Run: 5 Elections won (1961–1974) - Country Party, (1998 - Present) - LIB
State Divisions: Part of Carine, Hillarys, Joondalup, part of Mindarie, Ocean Reef and part of Wanneroo
Assessment: Variable, safe LIB

 

O'Connor:

Incumbent: Tony Crook (NAT)
Incumbent/Party Run: 1 Elections won (2010 - Present)
2010 Margin (TPP): 3.56% against LIB
Electoral History: 1980-2010: LIB
2010 - Present: NAT
Longest Electoral Run: 11 Elections won (1980 - 2010) - LIB
State Divisions: Albany, part of Blackwood-Stirling, part of Central Wheatbelt, Eyre, part of Kalgoorlie, part of Pilbara and part of Wagin
Assessment: Variable, leaning to NAT

 

Pearce:

Incumbent: Judi Moylan (LIB)
Incumbent/Party Run: 7 Elections won (1993 - Present)
8 Elections won (1990 - Present)
2010 Margin (TPP): 8.86% against ALP
Electoral History: 1990-Present: LIB
Longest Electoral Run: 8 Elections won (1990 - Present) - LIB
State Divisions: Part of Central Wheatbelt, part of Darling Range, part of Kalamunda, part of Midland, part of Mindarie, part of Moore, part of Swan Hills and part of West Swan
Assessment: Stable, safe LIB

 

Perth:

Incumbent: Stephen Smith (ALP)
Incumbent/Party Run: 7 Elections won (1993 - Present)
13 Elections won (1983 - Present)
2010 Margin (TPP): 5.88% against LIB
Electoral History: 1901–1909: ALP
1909–1917: Commonwealth Liberal Party
1917–1929: Nationalist Party
1929–1929: IND Nationalist***
1929–1931: Nationalist Party
1931–1943: United Australia Party
1943–1955: ALP
1955–1969: LIB
1969–1975: ALP
1975–1983: LIB
1983–present: ALP
Longest Electoral Run: 13 Elections won (1983 - Present) - ALP
(Including predecessors of LIB and aligned Independents as one party, there were also 13 Elections won (1909 - 1943))
State Divisions: Bassendean, Maylands, part of Morley, part of Mount Lawley and part of Perth
Assessment: Stable, safe ALP

 

Stirling:

Incumbent: Michael Keenan (LIB)
Incumbent/Party Run: 3 Elections won (2004 - Present)
2010 Margin (TPP): 5.55% against ALP
Electoral History: 1955–1958: ALP
1958–1961: LIB
1961–1972: ALP
1972–1983: LIB
1983–1993: ALP
1993–1998: LIB
1998–2004: ALP
2004–present: LIB
Longest Electoral Run: 5 Elections won (1972–1983) - LIB
State Divisions: Balcatta, part of Carine, part of Girrawheen, part of Morley, part of Mount Lawley, part of Nollamara and part of Scarborough
Assessment: Variable, safe LIB

 

Swan:

Incumbent: Steve Irons (LIB)
Incumbent/Party Run: 2 Elections won (2007 - Present)
2010 Margin (TPP): 2.53% against ALP
Electoral History: 1901–1909: Protectionist Party
1909–1917: Commonwealth Liberal Party*
1917–1918: Nationalist Party
1918–1919: ALP
1919–1943: Country Party
1943–1943: IND Country Party***
1943–1946: ALP
1946–1949: Country Party
1949–1954: LIB
1954–1955: ALP
1955–1969: LIB
1969–1975: ALP
1975–1980: LIB
1980–1996: ALP
1996–1998: LIB
1998–2007: ALP
2007–present: LIB
Longest Electoral Run: 9 Elections won (1919 - 1943) - Country Party
State Divisions: Part of Belmont, part of Cannington, part of Riverton, South Perth and Victoria Park
Assessment: Volatile leaning to LIB

 

Tangney:

Incumbent: Dennis Jenson (LIB)
Incumbent/Party Run: 3 Elections won (2004 - Present)
10 Elections won (1984 - Present)
2010 Margin (TPP): 12.32% against ALP
Electoral History: 1974–1975: ALP
1975–1977: LIB
1977–1977: Progress Party
1977–1983: LIB
1983–1984: ALP
1984–present: LIB
Longest Electoral Run: 10 Elections won (1984 - Present) - LIB
State Divisions: Part of Alfred Cove, Bateman, part of Jandakot, part of Riverton, part of Southern River and part of Willagee
Assessment: Stable, very safe LIB


*Although listed in blue as a predecessor of the modern Liberal party, it is important to note that these parties are break-away groups and originally part of the Labor Party. Thus they cannot be viewed as entirely aligned with the modern Labor or Liberal positions. The same non-equivalence is true -- though to a lesser extent -- with the other, now defunct, historical parties.

**The Western Australian Party did not officially merge into the Commonwealth Liberal Party, but many of its members (including its only elected member in Fremantle) did join the CLP. The WA Party was formed from members of the Protectionist Party and Anti-Socialist Party, and thus can be seen as another subgroup of the predecessors of the modern Liberal Party. However, it is an anomaly, so I have included it under its official party colour (cyan) instead of Liberal blue.

***If you are confused by Independents who are also party affiliated, then you are in good company. To oversimplify, an Independent Labor candidate (for example) is an Independent who will by and large act as, and believes in the same principles as, a Labor candidate. 

For a really good explanation of the insanity that ensues, I recoment Dr Kevin Bonham's post What is an independent liberal from the Tasmanian LegCo elections this year, which contains a discussion about endorsed unendorsed candidates and unendorsed unendorsed candidates.

Saturday, 15 June 2013

District Run-Down (1 of 6) - South Australia

Once again I will not be available next week to write the blogpost, so I will be preparing it in advance. It may not be topical, but at least it will be available. I bring this up here because next week's post will be a continuation of a long post-athon summarising the seats of this election.

Today we start with my home state of South Australia, and run down through the other states in the order that they are likely to be most relevant to my readers. Second W.A., where I have a couple of at least semi-regular readers, then Victoria, where I may have another. After that we move to Queensland where I have a contact who might occasionally take an interest.

New South Wales comes next, purely as a result of being geographically larger and economically more influential than Tasmania. With that last state I will also cover the N.T. and A.C.T.:

June 15th: South Australia
June 22nd: Western Australia
June 29th: Victoria
July 6th: Queensland 
July 13th: New South Wales
July 20th: Tasmania, Northern Territory and Australian Capital Territory
And so, to business:

South Australia:

The largest employment groups in South Australia are health care and support services, retail and manufacturing (source). The state government is bicameral and based on the Westminster system. The lower house (House of Assembly) contains 26 Labor members, 18 Liberal and 3 Independent. The upper house (Legislative Council) is held by 8 Labor councillors, 7 Liberals, 2 councillors each from Family First, Greens and No Pokies and 1 from Dignity 4 Disability.

The state contains 11 electoral districts, and as a state elects 6 Senators to the Federal Parliament.

How to Read These Summaries:

Incumbent: Incumbent lists the current member for the seat and their current party.

Incumbent/Party Run: Incumbent run provides the number of elections won by the current member, and the years of those elections in parentheses. By-elections are ignored.

A second line may be present and indicate the number of elections won by the current member's party, if this is different to the number won by the current member. Again the years of those elections in parentheses, and again by-elections are ignored.

2010 Margin (TPP): This is the margin by which the seat was won after the last redistribution of preferences in the 2010 federal election, and who this margin was against.

Electoral History: A list of previous incumbent parties from the foundation of the seat to the present.

Longest Electoral Run: The most elections won in a row in this seat by one party, with the years of those elections in parentheses and the party which won the seat in those elections.

State Divisions: The state seats within this federal seat. The seat names are coloured according to their current incumbent (red for ALP, Blue for Liberal, grey for Independents). The last state election was in 2010. Port Adelaide and Ramsay had simultaneous by-elections in 2012. Both remained ALP seats, were unchallenged by Liberal candidates and were won with a margin against an Independent.

Assessment: An assessment of the seats political history - that is, whether the seat is traditionally of one party or another. This is only approximated from the data here, does not constitute a prediction and may differ from the current incumbent's party.

Adelaide:

Incumbent: Kate Ellis (ALP)
Incumbent/Party Run: 3 Elections won (2004 - Present)
2010 Margin (TPP): 7.69% against LIB
Electoral History: 1903-1908: Protectionist Party
1908-1919: ALP
1919-1922: Nationalist Party
1922-1931: ALP
1931-1943: United Australia Party
1943-1966: ALP
1966-1969: LIB
1969-1988: ALP
1988-1990: LIB
1990-1993: ALP
1993-2004: LIB
2004-Present: ALP
Longest Electoral Run: 9 Elections won (1943 - 1966) - ALP
State Divisions: Adelaide, part of Ashford, part of Bragg, part of Croydon, part of Enfield, part of Norwood, part of Torrens, Unley and part of West Torrens.
Assessment: Volatile, leaning to ALP

Barker:

Incumbent: Patrick Secker (LIB)
Incumbent/Party Run: 5 Elections won (1998 - Present)
26 Elections won (1946 - Present)
2010 Margin (TPP): 12.88% against ALP
Electoral History: 1903-1906: Protectionist Party
1906-1909: Anti-Socialist Party
1909-1917: Commonwealth Liberal Party*
1917-1922: Nationalist Party
1922-1925: Liberal Union
1925-1931: Nationalist Party
1931-1934: United Australia Party
1934-1940: Country Party
1940-1944: United Australia Party
1944-Present: LIB
Longest Electoral Run: 26 Elections won (1946 - Present) - LIB
(Including predecessors of LIB, 42 Elections won (1903 - Present))
Component Divisions: Chaffey, part of Hammond, part of Kavel, part of Light, Mackillop, Mount Gambier, part of Schubert and part of Stuart
Assessment: Stable, very safe LIB

Boothby:

Incumbent: Andrew Southcott (LIB)
Incumbent/Party Run: 6 Elections won (1996 - Present)
25 Elections won (1949 - Present)
2010 Margin (TPP): 0.75% against ALP
Electoral History: 1903–1911: ALP
1911–1913: Commonwealth Liberal Party*
1913–1916: ALP
1916–1917: National Labor Party*
1917–1922: Nationalist Party
1922–1925: Liberal Union
1925–1928: Nationalist Party
1928–1931: ALP
1931–1943: United Australia Party
1943–1949: ALP
1949-present: LIB
Longest Electoral Run: 25 Elections won (1949 - Present) - LIB
Component Divisions: part of Bright, part of Davenport, part of Elder, part of Fisher, part of Mitchell, part of Morphett, part of Unley and Waite
Assessment: Stable, safe LIB (despite small margin)

Grey:

Incumbent: Rowan Ramsey (LIB)
Incumbent/Party Run: 2 Elections won (2007 - Present)
7 Elections won (1993 - Present)
2010 Margin (TPP): 11.16% against ALP
Electoral History: 1903–1916: ALP
1916–1917: National Labor Party*
1917–1922: Nationalist Party
1922–1931: ALP
1931–1937: United Australia Party
1937–1940: Country Party
1940–1943: United Australia Party
1943–1966: ALP
1966–1969: LIB
1969–1993: ALP
1993–present: LIB
Longest Electoral Run: 10 Elections won (1943 - 1966) - ALP
Component Divisions: Flinders, part of Frome, Giles, part of Goyder and part of Stuart
Assessment: Variable, safe LIB

Hindmarsh:

Incumbent: Steve Georganas (ALP)
Incumbent/Party Run: 3 Elections won (2004 - Present)
2010 Margin (TPP): 5.70% against LIB
Electoral History: 1903–1916: ALP
1916–1917: National Labor Party*
1917–1919: Nationalist Party
1919–1993: ALP
1993–2004: LIB
2004–present: ALP
Longest Electoral Run: 29 Elections won (1919 - 1993) - ALP
Component Divisions: Part of Ashford, part of Colton, part of Croydon, part of Elder, part of Lee, part of Morphett and part of West Torrens
Assessment: Variable, safe ALP

Kingston:

Incumbent: Amanda Rishworth ALP
Incumbent/Party Run: 2 Elections won (2007 - Present)
2010 Margin (TPP):
Electoral History: 1949–1951: LIB
1951–1966: ALP
1966–1969: LIB
1969–1975: ALP
1975–1983: LIB
1983–1996: ALP
1996–1998: LIB
1998–2004: ALP
2004–2007: LIB
2007–present: ALP
Longest Electoral Run: 6 Elections won (1951 - 1966)
Component Divisions: Part of Bright, part of Finniss, part of Fisher, Kaurna, part of Mitchell, Mawson and Reynell
Assessment: Volatile, tossup

Makin:

Incumbent: Tony Zappia (ALP)
Incumbent/Party Run: 2 Elections won (2007-Present)
2010 Margin (TPP): 12.20% against LIB
Electoral History: 1984-1996: ALP
1996-2007: LIB
2007-Present: ALP
Longest Electoral Run: 4 Elections won (1984-1996) - ALP, (1996-2007) - LIB
Component Divisions: Part of Florey, part of Little Parra, part of Newland, Playford and Wright
Assessment: Volatile, safe ALP

Mayo:

Incumbent: Jamie Briggs (LIB)
Incumbent/Party Run: 1 Election won (2008-Present)
10 Elections won (1984-Present)
2010 Margin (TPP): 17.35% against ALP
Electoral History: 1984-Present: LIB
Longest Electoral Run: 10 Elections won (1984-Present) - LIB
Component Divisions: Part of Bragg, part of Davenport, part of Finniss, part of Fisher, part of Hammond, part of Heysen, part of Kavel, part of Morialta, part of Newland and part of Schubert
Assessment: Stable, very safe LIB

Port Adelaide:

Incumbent: Mark Butler (ALP)
Incumbent/Party Run: 2 Elections won (2007-Present)
25 Elections won (1949-Present)
2010 Margin (TPP): 20.03% against LIB
Electoral History: 1949-Present: ALP
Longest Electoral Run: 25 Elections won (1949-Present) - ALP
Component Divisions: Cheltanham, part of Colton, part of Croydon, part of Enfield, part of Lee, Port Adelaide, part of Ramsay and part of Taylor
Assessment: Stable, very safe ALP

Sturt:

Incumbent: Christopher Pyne (LIB)
Incumbent/Party Run:  7 Elections won (1993-Present)
16 Elections won (1972-Present)
2010 Margin (TPP): 3.43% against ALP
Electoral History: 1949–1954: LIB
1954–1955: ALP
1955–1969: LIB
1969–1972: ALP
1972–present: LIB
Longest Electoral Run: 16 Elections won (1972-Present) - LIB
Component Divisions: Part of Bragg, part of Florey, Hartley, part of Morialta, part of Newland, part of Norwood, part of Torrens and part of Unley.
Assessment: Stable, safe LIB

Wakefield:

Incumbent: Nick Champion (ALP)
Incumbent/Party Run: 2 Elections won (2007-Present)
2010 Margin (TPP): 11.95% against LIB
Electoral History: 1903–1909: IND
1909–1917: Commonwealth Liberal Party*
1917–1922: Nationalist Party
1922–1925: Liberal Union
1925–1928: Nationalist Party
1928–1929: Country Party
1929–1931: Nationalist Party
1931–1938: United Australia Party
1938–1940: ALP
1940–1943: United Australia Party
1943–1946: ALP
1946-2007: LIB
2007–present: ALP
Longest Electoral Run: 23 Elections won (1946-2007) - LIB
Component Divisions: Part of Frome, part of Goyder, part of Light, part of Little Parra, Napier, part of Ramsay, part of Schubert, part of Stuart and part of Taylor.
Assessment: Variable, leaning to ALP

*Although listed in blue as a predecessor of the modern Liberal party, it is important to note that these parties are break-away groups and originally part of the Labor Party. Thus they cannot be viewed as entirely aligned with the modern Labor or Liberal positions. The same non-equivalence is true -- though to a lesser extent -- with the other, now defunct, historical parties.

Saturday, 8 June 2013

Aves Et Apes (Et Vespertili)

Australia was federated in 1901, and our first federal parliament was replaced by an election held on December 16, 1903.

110 years on, we are facing a very different election. A lot has changed in the last century. Twenty years ago mobile phones and the Internet were emerging, groundbreaking developments.

Only fifty years ago Aboriginal Australians were not counted in the calculation of how many seats each state got in Parliament. They would not be counted until the passing of the 1967 referendum (although they were legally allowed to vote since the introduction of Australian Citizenship in 1949). The idea of a female Prime Minister in Australia, or an African-American President in the US, were seen as distant dreams by idealists.

Seventy years ago, during the Second World War, cars were still novel and home television was a new emergence.

In 1903, the only one of these developments considered to be plausible in a practical way was the car. And back then they looked like this:

On the upside there was no Fast and Furious franchise;
on the downside, a 1903 Fast and Furious would have been great.


These are just some of the changes that have altered the basics of political life. Most people would appreciate and embrace the benefits these advantages have brought. Politics has a role to play in encouraging this progress, particularly social progress. Sadly, further progress is needed.

Today there are 66 women in parliament (37 in the House of Reps and 29 in the Senate) which is around one-in-three. This is important not only because it brings a diverse range of views and opinions to the government, but because - to compare government to business as many misguided politicians do - repeated studies have shown companies perform significantly better when there is gender diversity in leadership positions.

This is promising, although there is obvious room for improvement. I reported a while back on a study that suggested that donkey voting is significantly less likely if it gives the first preference to a woman. It is not impossible that male candidates may have an edge in Australian elections, being seen as stronger, firmer and less emotional by a small but crucial number of voters.

Da-na-na-na Na-na-na-na Batman!

Recently in the Electoral District of Batman, publicly recognised as the coolest named electoral district in the country, one of Labor's most promising female potential candidates has pulled out of the race. Now, here's a little info about Batman:

Fast and Furious would be better with Batmobiles, too...
Firstly, it's pronounced /beɪt·mÉ™n/, but we will forgive them that.

Secondly, it has been around since federation. It has been a Labor seat since before the Second World War, with the exception of independent Sam Benson in 1966. Benson was the first independent to win a seat in 20 years, and had the advantage that he had previously held the seat for four years as a Labor candidate.

Thirdly, in the last election Batman was retained with over 52% of the primary vote. That means a swing of more than 2% might still not win another party the seat even if they get all the other preferences! The two party preferred opponent here is not the Liberal party, or any other Coalition party. In second place are the left-wing Australian Greens. And even if the Greens win the seat, they will side with Labor on most of the votes in parliament. So it is an understatement to state that it is an understatement to state that this is safe Labor ground. Try and get your head around that!

In the past, getting preselected by the ALP for this seat was basically the same as recieving a free government pension. This is less the case with the slide against Labor over the last few years, but Batman is still a much prized seat.

On the last day of May, ACTU boss Ged Kearney was thought to be the running to be Batman's first female member by several sources, saying that she was "considering it". On the first day of June she announced she would not run (again reported by several sources). It has been suggested that she was pressured not to run by the right-wing faction of the party who wish to support Senator David Feeney. If the name is familiar, it is because he was supposedly one of the "faceless men".

I figure they at lest have mouths, since they are able to pressure people into things.
Now perhaps she was pressured not to run. And perhaps that is the reason Ged pulled out of the race. And perhaps the pressure was because she was a woman.

Or perhaps not.

Either way the story has certainly been spun that way. The implication is always that Labor's faceless men -- who put Gillard in power -- are sexists. Regardless of the truth of any of the assumptions, if we accept Kearney was opposed on the grounds of her sex then there is an important question that is not asked: was the opposition to her as a woman the result of sexism in the party, or is it the result of political tactics. Perhaps it is the voters, not the politicians, who are sexist.

If, for example, women polled 3% less support than men - all else being equal - then it would be too dangerous to put a woman in the seat of Batman. After all, if Labor loses the seat then Kearney would not have got into Parliament anyhow.

Now I'm not going to get into my personal feelings on the subject, or whether such polling information would justify encouraging Ms Kearney to pull out. I am not convinced her sex was a factor at all, and I believe it is quite possible that no pressure was applied, since the right would have backed Feeney anyhow and Ms Kearney may well have known that she would have been trounced in the pre-selection.

I am merely interested in the statistical question; do female candidates receive less votes? Already I've mentioned this may be true purely from the donkey-vote point of view, but does sexual discrimination at the ballot stretch further than this? Even putting aside the social equality issue, it is an interesting question purely from a predictive psephological point of view.

Ladies and Gentlemen:

There are some quick stats on gender provided by the AEC.

Last election there were 619 men nominated as candidates, and only 230 women. Women, therefore, made up only about 27% of the candidates. Looking at the two major parties, women made up only 31% of ALP candidates and 20% of the Liberal party. Including the Nationals, CLP and LNQ, this dropped to just over 19% of Coalition candidates. Data for all of the parties are provided below:

Data from the AEC.
However, this may not entirely be the fault of the political parties. Less than 21% of Independents were women, suggesting fewer women are trying to get into politics in the first place. Perhaps politically savvy women feel that they will be at a disadvantage in an election. Perhaps the persistent problem of wage inequality makes running a campaign unaffordable for many female would-be-politicians. Perhaps the expectation on a mother to raise her children while the father works dissuades potential leaders from entering the arena.

However I personally know many strong, determined and intelligent women who would (and will, and do) make fantastic leaders outside of politics. I cannot believe that if any of these women had the specific ambition of entering government they could not at least get onto the ballot. But then perhaps I move in similar circles to the 21% who make it.

In the early days of women in the workforce, the hard part was not getting jobs. Female secretaries and assistants were not uncommon. The problem was moving up the ladder. The glass ceiling. The invisible barrier between women and promotion to the top.

Getting onto the ballot is not the hard part. It is getting elected that is the real contest. After all, the question we are chiefly concerned with this week is voter responses to female candidates, since these may explain the behaviours of parties and the reluctance of would-be Independents.

With women making less than 27.1% of the candidates, and yet over 29.2% of the parliament, it might seem that women have no difficulty getting elected once on the ballot.

Now a lot of my calculations here use imperfect data, back of the envelope calculations and a subjective selection of which parties to include or exclude from those calculations. I am the first to admit that my data is biased and lacks a lot of finesse that you might expect from a professional, but I am not a professional and I don't pretend to be. I also try to announce those biases wherever I spot them.

I am purely interested in developing rough systems that let me approximate electoral outcomes, so I have no problem with people who subjectively choose to take that simplistic stat and run with it. However I want to delve a little deeper and try and weed out some of the other possible variables throwing up some interferrence.

For example, if parties are concerned that female candidates may be a liability in close-run seats, then women will mostly stand in safe seats, and it should be no surprise that they are overrepresented in the parliament (as a proportion of the candidates, I mean). Also pro-women PACs like EMILY's list may help some women across the line once pre-selected, which may counter the general voting trend for those other, unsupported candidates.

Likewise it would prove nothing to look at the percentage of the primary vote women get in such seats. Instead, I'm going to look at swing for or against women as opposed to men. While this won't actually show how women perform on their own merits, it should indicate if support for women is subject to the tides of public opinion more than that of men.

The thing is, I don't thing many people go to the ballot thinking 'I won't vote for A because she is a woman'. I think how an individual votes is a cocktail of many factors, and policy - for example - will normally trump sex.

Here is my hypothesis on how sex would influence voters: if a voter is subject to this hypothetical sexist influence, it could determine which way the vote falls in an otherwise equal contest. If the general swing is against a party, the gender of a candidate could be enough to push the vote over the line to the other side. Conversely, when the swing is towards a candidate, that candidate's sex could be enough to repel some of the wave. If this were the case we would therefore expect to see swings skewed towards candidates of one sex and away from the other.

As I said, I try to announce my biases. In the following analysis I have made some subjective choices regarding the statistics I use, and which seats I look at:

For simplicity I'm going to look at the swing in the TPP House of Representatives vote and ignore any contest where both TPP candidates are of the same sex, or where the TPP contest is not between Labor and the Coalition. I'm only looking at the 2010 federal election, since attitudes to women have changed over time and I want to keep to the most recent data.

Data from the AEC.

Before we start any analysis, a little background on these seats. In 2010 the average magnitude of the swing for all seats was marginally greater than 4% of the voting public. The average magnitude for these seats is in the range of 3.5%, so these seats were less volatile. This does not mean they were safer in terms of proportion of seats changing hands or size of their margins, merely that the net change in voter opinion was not as extreme in these seats as in others.

The average swing against the ALP in these 54 seats is around 2.2. Where Labor's candidate was the female in the equation this dropped to less than 1.9%. Where the Coalition's candidate was female, swing away from Labor averaged closer to 2.9%. In other words, the average swing was in fact skewed toward the female candidates. If anything female candidates perform better than men in elections (in terms of swing, at least.)

Now I haven't factored in incumbency. Nor have I factored in the possibility that some of these candidates may not be the same person (or even the same sex as the person) who ran in 2007 (and thus against whom the swing's baseline is calculated). However it is worth noting that of the 16 seats above that exhibited against-the-trend swings towards Labor, 13 were towards female candidates.

So perhaps that simple back-of-the-envelope equation we did before is right. Perhaps, once on the ballot, women do not struggle any more than men to get elected. It would seem that pre-selection is the actual limiting factor.

Not so much a glass ceiling as a glass doorway.

Saturday, 1 June 2013

How to Hold an Election

From an electoral perspective, not much is happening around this time of year. The initial election buzz has worn off the media, and there won't be any solid stuff to write about candidates or interesting seats until the writs are issued in August and we know who we've got on the ballots.

There is, however, plenty to write about still. The problem is that most of the useful (and plenty of useless) analytical stuff has either already been covered here (past voting trends, margins etc.) or is not yet available (final polling data etc.).

I could (and still might) get some more ABS maps and compare various demographics with past voting trends to confirm or refute the common impressions that, for example, the elderly more often vote for the Coalition and urban populations regularly vote Labor. However, the results will be a little vague as a result of trying to match ABS statistical divisions with electorates. If I have the time I could actually look up the actual census data for a more detailed and accurate analysis.

I could also do a seat-by-seat breakdown for each state and look in detail at voting history, attitudes and demographics, so look forward to that! (I'll try to keep it interesting for people more normal than myself, I promise.)

This week, however, I'm going to look at how an election is actually run. I've already covered how to vote, and I'll probably return to that closer to the election. This is the other half of that - the rules that govern everything except the voters.

Two Thirds of the Way to Anarchy:

The Government cannot just have an election of its own free will. If it could, then it could also not have an election of its own free will. As everyone knows, there are certain rules that govern federal and state/territory elections. For example, under normal circumstances there must be an election within three years and ninety-eight days of the return of the writs for the last election (we'll get to writs later). These rules are laid out in the constitution (or: The Commonwealth of Australia Constitution Act) which serves as the first law of the country, and upon which every other law, bill, political position, electoral process and just about everything else is based.

So the first question is: 'why is the maximum time between an election (under normal circumstances) three years and ninety-eight days'. It does seem a little odd, but that is because there are actually four periods covered. The first comes from Section 5 of the Constitution:
"After any general election the Parliament shall be summoned to meet not later than thirty days after the day appointed for the return of the writs."
The Parliament then lasts for a maximum of three years, as ascribed by Section 28. This is measured from the first sitting:
"Every House of Representatives shall continue for three years from the first meeting of the House, and no longer, but may be sooner dissolved by the Governor‑General"
This makes three years, thirty days. The next ten are the maximum delay between end of the sitting Parliament and the issuing of the writs for the next election. Or, as Section 32 puts it:
"After the first general election, the writs shall be issued within ten days from the expiry of a House of Representatives or from the proclamation of a dissolution thereof."
The final fifty-eight days are the maximum delay between the issuing of the writs and the election. This comes not from the constitution, but form the Commonwealth Electoral Act 1918 (or CEA), and is a combination of Section 156, subsection (1):
"Subject to subsection (2), the date fixed for the nomination of the candidates shall not be less than 10 days nor more than 27 days after the date of the writ."
and Section 157:
The date fixed for the polling shall not be less than 23 days nor more than 31 days after the date of nomination
However, note that I always qualified the timeline with the phrase "under normal circumstances". That was my not-so-subtle way of covering myself, because there is one particular situation where this changes. The secret is in that little introductory clause for CEA Section 156, Subsection (1):

"Subject to subsection (2),..."

Well, subsection (2) states that:
Where a candidate for an election dies, after being nominated and before 12 o'clock noon on the day fixed by the writ as the date of nomination for the election, the day fixed as the date of nomination for the election shall, except for the purposes of section 157, be taken to be the day next succeeding the day so fixed
In other words, if a candidate dies before midday on the day of nomination, the day of nomination is delayed 24 hours out of respect, and possibly to allow his/her name to be removed from the ballots.

This stretches the time between elections to three years, ninety-nine days. Now I know what you're thinking. You're thinking that a systematic, organised campaign of assassinating candidates before midday, each day from nomination day onwards could perpetually delay the election. You're thinking that with 849 candidates for the lower house in 2010 you could delay the election a further 849 days making it five years, two-hundred and seventeen days between an election, and that by then more candidates might have signed up, leading to a perpetual suspension of the legislative and executive branches of the Australian Government. You're thinking of laughing manically, building a secret lair under a volcano and hiring expendable henchmen.

Well, no, you can't. For one thing it's actually illegal to kill 849 people to delay a federal election. For another, subsection (2) prevents this. Twice. Lets say, hypothetically, that the date of nomination prescribed in the writs is a Monday. And let's assume, just for the sake of it, that the day after that is a Friday. Yes, its unnecessarily complicated and chronologically nonsensical, but what the heck. If a candidate dies before midday Monday, the deadline for nominations is delayed 24 hours until Friday.

Now, if someone dies before midday Friday, the nomination date is not pushed back another 24 hours to, lets say, Tuesday. There are two reasons for this. Firstly, this only applies if the candidate dies "before 12 o'clock noon on the day fixed by the writ".

Secondly, even if the second death did somehow enact the delay, the extension is worded to continue until "the day next succeeding the day so fixed" (i.e. the day after Monday (i.e. Friday)). It doesn't matter how many times the extension is applied, the delay only lasts until the day after the day fixed in the writs (which is the Friday (the day after the Monday) and not the Tuesday (the day after that))!
Now I have an urge to write coverage for the election of the President of the Supreme Council of Gallifrey and All Her Dominions...

Rightly Written Writs:

A writ is simply a formal order. In the case of a writ of election, it is the piece of paper that creates the election as a legal entity. In practical terms, this is the real calling of an election, and each writ will contain the dates for:
  • The the close of the rolls (i.e. the last date to enrole to vote) which is always 7 days after the writ (CEA s.115),
  • The nomination (i.e. the last day to put your name forward as a candidate) as outlined above,
  • The polling (i.e. the vote itself) which must be a Saturday (CEA s.158) 23 to 31 days after the nomination (CEA s.157)
  • The return of the writ (the date when the writ must be returned, effectively the end of the election) within 100 days of the writ (CEA s.159) which allows for 41 days after the election (including the 24 hour delay caused by the death of a nominee) during which to determine who won each seat and attach their names to the writ.
A writ takes effect from 6 PM on the day it is issued, and is issued by the Governor-General. The Governor-General has traditionally issued writs at the request and advice of the Prime Minister, although this is not a legal requirement and the writs could be issued today if the GG so desired. It is a bit misleading to say the PM calls an election, although the media will often report this as such.

One writ must be issued for each of the current states and territories. In the CEA, Section 154 they are each named specifically, which means if a new state or territory is added to the Commonwealth (as is allowed in the Constitution, Section 121) and the CEA is not updated, that state/territory will not get a vote. (Editor: This is probably to deal with cases like Norfolk Island.)

In the case of a general election (what I casually refer to as a federal election) all electoral divisions must be elected on the same day and the writs must all be returned by the same deadline (CEA s.160). (In the case of a by-election, writs can be issued for individual electorates or groups of electorates, and as such may have individual polling and return of writ dates.)
 

The Thing Upstairs:

The Senate, of course, does things differently. When do they ever not?

Each state's senators have their elections run on a different timetable to the lower house, and do not need to coincide with the lower house elections (although for simplicity they regularly do). Senators serve a 6-year term, and half are replaced every three years. A senator's term begins on July 1, and the election for that senate seat must be held in the year preceding the seat becoming vacant, ready for immediate switch over. All of this is laid out in Section 13 of the Constitution.

Writs for senate seats in each state are issued not by the Governor General, but by that state's Governor, according to Section 12 of the Constitution. Section 151 of the Commonwealth Electoral Act of 1918, however, states that the Governor-General will issue the writs for territories, and that these are tied to the lower house election.

Further, the Governor-General can dissolve the entire Senate, for example in a double dissolution as allowed under Section 57 of the Constitution, and each state must issue writs for their senators within ten days of this being announced under Section 12.

That all complicates things, so its a good job the Governors-General and state Governors tend to work so well together. A lot of this is a relic of federation, where individual states were concerned about losing their autonomy. In practice, the Governors tend to lump the Senate elections in with the House of Representatives where allowed by the timetables set out by the Constitution. 

Those who advocate fixed term elections (thus preventing politicians from "calling" an early election when they are most popular, or delaying when they are least) would generally advocate for a much simpler system where all federal senate seats are tied to House of Reps elections. But until then, politicians won't be "calling" elections at all, and the Senate will do as the State Governors direct.

Saturday, 25 May 2013

In a Rich Man's World

So last week I made you all sit through a summary of the Labor budget, and threw in a few pretty pictures to keep you interested. Now we're going to do the fun bit -- or for those of you with no sense of edge-of-your-seat-adventure, the interpretation bit.

I mentioned that this kind of economic prediction is very difficult to do with any accuracy -- not least because the extent to which budget spending influences votes is not only very hard to calculate, but varies from year to year and community to community.

However, for obvious reasons, the role of the budget will be greater where all other factors are evenly balanced: in other words, in marginal seats. So what I'm going to do here is say boo to accurate predictions based on this data alone. And I'm going to say a slightly quieter boo to predictions factoring in existing margins, polling, voting history, traditional voting of demographics, targeted campaign strategies, ideology and promises and the like ... for now.

What I am going to do is work out roughly how people would vote if financial benefit were the only consideration in their vote. This will assume all financial benefit is equal, so a million dollars of funding is given equal weight regardless of how directly (or indirectly) it impacts the voters. Now obviously this is not how the real world works. One million dollars towards education is fantastic (a million dollars more fantastic than nothing, at least) but it will mean less to parents than a million dollars towards disability services would mean to the disabled and their carers (even if we assume there are as many parents as disabled people and carers).

So the calculations are cheap and nasty, but that is okay because they will not be a major plank in our raft of prediction tools - simply another factor to consider in close-run seats. Besides, we're still working with 2006 data anyway, so we're going to have to live with some inaccuracies.

So here are the maps:


Firstly, here is a map of seats gaining funding between the five initiatives outlined last week: (N.B. some averaging and approximation was necessary where electoral seats did not match up with ABS statistical divisions. Generalisations have been made, and urban seats are inaccurate due to the low resolution of ABS maps.)



For this map, each sheet was shaded with pure green (#00FF00) at an opacity level equal to the number of people affected by the funding gains. The intensity of the colour, therefore, shows the percentage of people won over by the pension, school and disability increases.

It is assumed that the benefits from the programs mentioned last week are independent of each other. In other words in an area with ~10% of the population aged 55-64 and ~5% living with a disability, the total people benefiting from the two initiatives related to these demographics is not 15% of the population but 14.5%, since .5% (10% of 5%, or 5% of 10%) fit into both categories and should not be counted twice. At first this seems illogical when we allow for a person between 55 and 64 to also vote according to the aged 4-and-under factor, but this is because people close to retirement may have children in that age bracket and act accordingly. None of the demographics are exclusive of any other - A 55 year old disabled man attending university and raising a school age child while his wife is pregnant would be rare, but would also be affected by all five budget measures.

As we can see the distribution is surprisingly even. There is a slight advantage to seats in southeastern states, but not one that is noticeable on this map.

Here is another map, showing places loosing funding:


Again, the burden is rather evenly spread. The concentration in urban areas is slightly more noticeable than the concentrations in the previous map. This is largely the result of the university cuts.

However, we need to remember that not all of this funding is equal. Different measures cost different amounts and benefit or disadvantage people to different extents. The above map demonstrates the population densities where people are aided or disadvantaged. The following map factors in how much their are aided or disadvantaged. The above map shows the government's target demographics, the one below shows the extent of the impact in average dollars per person.







Here, the intensity of the colour is relative to the amount of money gained per person on average. It is the benefit per targeted person multiplied by the proportion of people benefited. So 10% of the population gaining a $100 boost is valued here on par with 100% of the population gaining a $10 bonus. The problem with this model is that giving $5 billion to one person in Sydney is the same as giving $1000 to everyone in Sydney, although the latter will clearly get you more votes.

Here is a map where the amount of money is not a factor. votes can be bought for a fraction of a cent, and spending almost 20,000 per targeted person (e.g. the NDIS) is worth no more or less than handing out loose change on the street corner.



This makes the distinctions between winners and losers a little clearer. Again the metropolitan areas are feeling the university cuts, but over all the nation is in the green. And in practical terms this is probably a closer mirror to the thinking of people who vote according to personal benefit; they don't compare themselves to others along the lines of 'the money I got in my old age pension boost is only about 5% of what they get under the National Disability Insurance Scheme'. They merely want to know if they have more than they did before - and if the opposition will see and raise the government's promises.

The problem for the opposition is that they need to try to offer more money to more people while ensuring greater savings. Or do they?

How to Frame a Budget from the Other Side of the Floor:


The budget reply came as a big surprise to many. The opposition agreed with the bulk of Labor's proposed budget recommendations. There was none of the normal game playing, such as blaming Labor for the deficit and not supplying a surplus. Programs were not opposed simply because Labor proposed them. It was an odd day for many, however it was a fantastically well thought out move.

Firstly, in the last budget Abbott did not promise the kind of immediate return to surplus many half-interested voters assume he intends to give. The Coalition has already done the groundwork on this. If a budget surplus is your top priority, the Lib-Nats have already framed themselves as the can-do candidates. And Abbott continued this theme by calling the situation an "emergency" which required such "objectionable" measures to be adopted. However, Mr Abbott has not promised unreasonable economic changes he cannot deliver - his reply is roughly equal in pragmatism to Labor's budget because it is a very similar deal.

More importantly, by agreeing on a lot of Labor's plans, he's taken the wind out of their sails. Any backlash - even post election and even if the Liberals come to power - will be against the Gillard government reforms. And by agreeing to Labor's terms on the baby bonus, the NDIS and most of the other budget plans, these are not going to win Labor much traction because they are not going to be debated. And this is the key to Abbott's budget reply. He has chosen where the two parties will differ, and he gets to frame the debate.

The key differences, and thus the main focus of this campaign, are the "carbon tax", the "mining tax" and "Gonski reforms". Importantly, only one of those is the term that Labor originally used to describe them. It is fair to say that many people do not fully understand the Carbon Tax or the Mining Tax. They sound like taxes on the common people, and sound like big ones. In one of the post-western-Sydney-trip reports on the ABC there was a shop owner concerned about how he needs to pay the carbon tax on top of the GST, income tax and the like. This is clearly one issue where the Coalition has clearly cut through more effectively than the Government.

The odd-one-out is the Gonski reforms, which are also poorly understood and somewhat nebulous as far as the average voter understands. There is increased funding for schools, sure, but how this funding is allocated (private vs public, infrastructure vs technology vs staffing) is all very confusing to anyone who doesn't have the time to sit down and read about the policy.

I could look at which areas will benefit the most from the scrapping of the "carbon pricing", the "mineral resource rent tax" and, to a lesser extent, the "Gonski reforms". But I suspect this is irrelevant, because the Coalition is selling this as a better deal for all Australians. And perhaps it is -- that is for the voters to decide -- but my point is this: Abbott's reply was not targeted at helping specific target demographics at the expense of the other. It was an exercise in downplaying Labor's strongest policies and framing the economic debate in terms he thinks he has the best chance of winning.

This is not necessarily a bad thing, and it is not necessarily a good thing. It is just a simplicity thing. Abbott might be hiding some further, more controversial measures he plans to bring in -- to do with "stopping the boats" perhaps -- by sweeping them under the carpet. Alternatively, these could simply be the core issues of his campaign, with nothing hidden by the time we reach the polls, which is why he has no declared plans to change industrial relations until the election after next.

Mr Abbott is offering a simple, easy to grasp choice. Perhaps this is the best response when Labor has trouble explaining their own policies so that the average voter can comprehend. Better the devil you understand...

Data Dump

This is a supplement to the post above. This does not count towards my limit of one post per week, and should be read in conjunction with the post to which it refers.

So, it's been a little while since I last did a data dump. This week's will be a little different to before, because the maps were largely derived from the ABS maps provided last week. Apart from these maps offering ranges rather than pure figures (and thus some inherent errors in this week's maps precision) this meant making assumptions wherever the boundaries did not match up - i.e. that each ABS division was homogenous and that its population was evenly distributed across the area.

Instead, I have the separate layers used to make the combined maps for you to ignore, and the raw data for working out how much was earned per person targeted by an initiative in the budget (and thus each layer's opacity for map 3).


Layers:

Superannuation – Benefits to Retirees

Demographic Distribution for Recipients of the Pension Increase

School Funding – Benefits to Parents of School-Aged Students



Demographic Distribution of School Aged Students

NDIS Benefits

Demographic Distribution of People Living with a Disability

University Indexation

Demographic Distribution of Tertiary Students

Baby Bonus Impacts

Demographic Distribution of the Parents of Young Children (as a Proxy for Expecting Parents)

 

Data:

 #  Pensioners will gain $35.50 per fortnight (source) which is around $925 per person annually. Note that couples pension increases by less (same source).

 # Schools are gaining $9.8 billion over 6 years (source), which is an average of $1.6 billion per year. With around 3.5 million school students (source) $1.6 billion a year is roughly $450 per student per year. Government funding schedules always seem to ramp up over time, so this is probably less initially.

 # The National Disability Insurance Scheme, which will support a projected 410,000 disabled people, carers and the like (source, p.6), costs $8 billion per year (source), or roughly 19,500 per person assisted.

  # I estimated the University Indexation to be around $3400 per student. Of course, the students aren't directly paying for all of this, that is just the financial cost of the services they would otherwise have had. (Note: this is not the cost of financial services lost, since university funding will still increase -- see last week's post for details -- nor is it the loss in value in real terms, since university numbers will increase sharing the burden but also straining resources.) This was based on a $2.8 billion dollar reduction (source) divided among roughly 830,000 domestic students in universities (source).

To be fair, not all of the tertiary education indexation is aimed at universities. Also, I could not find any data as to how many years this reduction was going to take place over, so I factored it all into a 12-month period from January. If this is a 5 year reduction, the per-student cost will drop per year. Further per-student drops in this impact may be calculated if you include foreign students or non-uni students who will share in some of the losses.

 # For the Baby Bonus, the cut is the whole $5,000 per child born (source). Also, this article suggests less than 30,000 families would have benefited in the next year. With a voting population of 16 million (source) last election, if each was in a relationship there would be 8 million couples. 30,000 of these expecting a child is around 0.4%. This is well below the minimum 5-10% of the population who actually had children born between 2002 and 2006 from last weeks census data. Part of this could be accounted for by twins, and part by the fact the census is data gives us the number of parents who had children over 4 years, as opposed to over a one year time span. And then there are parents who have two children within four years. And, of course, not everyone of voting age is in a relationship.

But all of this is irrelevant to some extent since the psychological effect (i.e. the effect which would play out during voting) is not to do with who will have a child -- and indeed anyone curently expecting will still receive the bonus -- but who might have a child. That includes parents trying for a child, or who plan to start a family in the near future. Whether or not this pans out in the long term these people will feel that they will lose out on the $5000 next electoion.

Both approximations (ABS data used and statistical number of actual births) are poor indicators of the voting demographic for hopeful parents, but in the absence of better figures this is the best I can offer. Treat the Baby Bonus data as a VERY rough guide. Considering how even the distribution on that map was, I don't think it had much of an overall effect, though.