Friday 25 October 2024

Queensland minority government, KAP in hand

As advised in last week's post, we'll only be giving this month's elections a cursory look.

Queensland's latest polling has the ALP behind in 2PP 49:51 and 47.5:52.5 from uComms and Newspoll respectively. This is a substantial swing from 2020 which saw the ALP win 53.2 of the 2PP vot: a swing of -4.2 to -5.7.

Applying these swings uniformly across all seats from the current pendulum gives the following baseline:

ELECTORATECURRENT-4.2 PP-5.7 PP
Algester17.813.612.1
Aspley5.21.0-0.5
Bancroft12.88.67.1
Barron River3.1-1.1-2.6
Bonney-10.1-14.3-15.8
Broadwater-16.6-20.8-22.3
Buderim-5.3-9.5-11.0
Bulimba11.47.25.7
Bundaberg0.0-4.2-5.7
BundambaN/AN/AN/A
Burdekin-7.0-11.2-12.7
Burleigh-1.2-5.4-6.9
Burnett-10.8-15.0-16.5
Cairns5.61.4-0.1
Callide-21.7-25.9-27.4
Caloundra2.5-1.7-3.2
Capalaba9.85.64.1
Chatsworth-1.3-5.5-7.0
Clayfield-1.6-5.8-7.3
Condamine-19.2-23.4-24.9
Cook6.32.10.6
Coomera-1.1-5.3-6.8
Cooper10.56.34.8
Currumbin-0.5-4.7-6.2
Everton-2.2-6.4-7.9
Ferny Grove11.06.85.3
Gaven7.83.62.1
Gladstone23.519.317.8
Glass House-1.6-5.8-7.3
Greenslopes13.29.07.5
Gregory-17.2-21.4-22.9
Gympie-8.5-12.7-14.2
Hervey Bay2.0-2.2-3.7
HillN/AN/AN/A
HinchinbrookN/AN/AN/A
Inala6.72.51.0
Ipswich16.512.310.8
Ipswich West-3.5-7.7-9.2
Jordan17.112.911.4
Kawana-9.3-13.5-15.0
Keppel5.61.4-0.1
Kurwongbah13.18.97.4
Lockyer-11.5-15.7-17.2
Logan13.49.27.7
Lytton13.49.27.7
Macalister9.55.33.8
Mackay6.72.51.0
MaiwarN/AN/AN/A
Mansfield6.82.61.1
Maroochydore-9.1-13.3-14.8
Maryborough11.97.76.2
McConnel11.16.95.4
Mermaid Beach-4.4-8.6-10.1
Miller13.89.68.1
MiraniN/AN/AN/A
Moggill-3.6-7.8-9.3
Morayfield16.712.511.0
Mount Ommaney12.68.46.9
Mudgeeraba-10.1-14.3-15.8
Mulgrave12.28.06.5
Mundingburra3.9-0.3-1.8
Murrumba11.37.15.6
Nanango-12.2-16.4-17.9
Nicklin0.1-4.1-5.6
Ninderry-4.1-8.3-9.8
NoosaN/AN/AN/A
Nudgee15.110.99.4
Oodgeroo-4.5-8.7-10.2
Pine Rivers6.72.51.0
Pumicestone5.31.1-0.4
Redcliffe6.11.90.4
Redlands3.9-0.3-1.8
Rockhampton8.64.42.9
Sandgate17.313.111.6
Scenic Rim-11.4-15.6-17.1
South BrisbaneN/AN/AN/A
Southern Downs-14.1-18.3-19.8
Southport-5.4-9.6-11.1
Springwood8.34.12.6
Stafford11.97.76.2
Stretton13.99.78.2
Surfers Paradise-16.2-20.4-21.9
Theodore-3.3-7.5-9.0
Thuringowa3.2-1.0-2.5
Toohey14.410.28.7
Toowoomba North-7.3-11.5-13.0
Toowoomba South-10.2-14.4-15.9
Townsville3.1-1.1-2.6
TraegerN/AN/AN/A
Warrego-23.1-27.3-28.8
Waterford16.011.810.3
Whitsunday-3.3-7.5-9.0
Woodridge26.222.020.5

Bundamba is also a safe ALP seat, shown as N/A here only because their dominance means LNP doesn't show up as the second party. With a margin of 20.7 against ONP, this can be safely predicted to remain ALP.

A number of the other 'N/A's are safe seats for parties other than ALP or LNP, and can be filled in easily due to the relatively small movement in minor party polling in the latest numbers compared to their 2020 result. Hill, Hinchinbrook and Traeger will remain with KAP and Noosa with Independent Sandy Bolton.

Though on slimmer margins, the Greens are polling marginally better than their 2020 performance so will likely hold Maiwar and South Brisbane too.

Mirani is the one oddity, won by ONP in 2020 but with the candidate switching to KAP this year. KAP did not contest the seat in 2020, so it's impossible to know how they would have done. It's anyone's guess whether incumbency and latent KAP support can hold the seat, dedicated ONP voters will reclaim it, or another (presumably major party (presumably LNP)) will swoop in. My guess is that a lot of the ONP vote in 2020 was anti-establishment conservative voters who would happily support KAP, putting this party above ONP and then on preferences retaining Mirani.

ELECTORATEPREDICTION
AlgesterALP
AspleyTBC
BancroftALP
Barron RiverLNP
BonneyLNP
BroadwaterLNP
BuderimLNP
BulimbaALP
BundabergLNP
BundambaALP
BurdekinLNP
BurleighLNP
BurnettLNP
CairnsTBC
CallideLNP
CaloundraLNP
CapalabaALP
ChatsworthLNP
ClayfieldLNP
CondamineLNP
CookALP
CoomeraLNP
CooperALP
CurrumbinLNP
EvertonLNP
Ferny GroveALP
GavenALP
GladstoneALP
Glass HouseLNP
GreenslopesALP
GregoryLNP
GympieLNP
Hervey BayLNP
HillKAP
HinchinbrookKAP
InalaALP
IpswichALP
Ipswich WestLNP
JordanALP
KawanaLNP
KeppelTBC
KurwongbahALP
LockyerLNP
LoganALP
LyttonALP
MacalisterALP
MackayALP
MaiwarGRN
MansfieldALP
MaroochydoreLNP
MaryboroughALP
McConnelALP
Mermaid BeachLNP
MillerALP
MiraniKAP
MoggillLNP
MorayfieldALP
Mount OmmaneyALP
MudgeerabaLNP
MulgraveALP
MundingburraLNP
MurrumbaALP
NanangoLNP
NicklinLNP
NinderryLNP
NoosaIND
NudgeeALP
OodgerooLNP
Pine RiversALP
PumicestoneTBC
RedcliffeALP
RedlandsLNP
RockhamptonALP
SandgateALP
Scenic RimLNP
South BrisbaneGRN
Southern DownsLNP
SouthportLNP
SpringwoodALP
StaffordALP
StrettonALP
Surfers ParadiseLNP
TheodoreLNP
ThuringowaLNP
TooheyALP
Toowoomba NorthLNP
Toowoomba SouthLNP
TownsvilleLNP
TraegerKAP
WarregoLNP
WaterfordALP
WhitsundayLNP
WoodridgeALP

Voila!

The remaining work is to call the four seats that would flip on a -5.7 pp swing from ALP to LNP but not -4.2 pp.

Cairns and Keppel only just flip (-0.1 pp margin) in the former scenario, so the safe bet on these is ALP retain. And based on nothing but a desire for balance this, I'm going to call Aspley and Pumicestone to flip to the LNP.

ELECTORATEPREDICTION
AlgesterALP
AspleyLNP
BancroftALP
Barron RiverLNP
BonneyLNP
BroadwaterLNP
BuderimLNP
BulimbaALP
BundabergLNP
BundambaALP
BurdekinLNP
BurleighLNP
BurnettLNP
CairnsALP
CallideLNP
CaloundraLNP
CapalabaALP
ChatsworthLNP
ClayfieldLNP
CondamineLNP
CookALP
CoomeraLNP
CooperALP
CurrumbinLNP
EvertonLNP
Ferny GroveALP
GavenALP
GladstoneALP
Glass HouseLNP
GreenslopesALP
GregoryLNP
GympieLNP
Hervey BayLNP
HillKAP
HinchinbrookKAP
InalaALP
IpswichALP
Ipswich WestLNP
JordanALP
KawanaLNP
KeppelALP
KurwongbahALP
LockyerLNP
LoganALP
LyttonALP
MacalisterALP
MackayALP
MaiwarGRN
MansfieldALP
MaroochydoreLNP
MaryboroughALP
McConnelALP
Mermaid BeachLNP
MillerALP
MiraniKAP
MoggillLNP
MorayfieldALP
Mount OmmaneyALP
MudgeerabaLNP
MulgraveALP
MundingburraLNP
MurrumbaALP
NanangoLNP
NicklinLNP
NinderryLNP
NoosaIND
NudgeeALP
OodgerooLNP
Pine RiversALP
PumicestoneLNP
RedcliffeALP
RedlandsLNP
RockhamptonALP
SandgateALP
Scenic RimLNP
South BrisbaneGRN
Southern DownsLNP
SouthportLNP
SpringwoodALP
StaffordALP
StrettonALP
Surfers ParadiseLNP
TheodoreLNP
ThuringowaLNP
TooheyALP
Toowoomba NorthLNP
Toowoomba SouthLNP
TownsvilleLNP
TraegerKAP
WarregoLNP
WaterfordALP
WhitsundayLNP
WoodridgeALP

This gives ALP 40 seats, LNP 46 and no-one the necessary 47 for majority government.

Labour would need every crossbench MP's support to form government, which is a big ask. Liberal Nationals only need one more person, but with the Greens having ruled out such a deal and a single independent leaving the government vulnerable at the first resignation or defection, both parties would be keen to court Katter's Australian Party. LNP has the stronger path to making 47, and of the two parties is the more natural ally of the KAP.

All of which is to say there will be a LNP minority government in a tense coalition with KAP.